The Caribbean Mystery poster
Where to stream

The Caribbean Mystery

6.719451h 5mNRMovieCrimeDramaMystery

The Caribbean Mystery is a remake of Mr. Moto on Danger Island (1939)-which in turn was a remake of Murder in Trinidad. James Dunn stars as Mr. Smith, a Columbo-like Brooklyn detective who pops up on a tropical island to track down some missing geologists.

DirectorRobert D. Webb
WritersLeonard Praskins·Jack Andrews
ProducerWilliam Girard

Where to watch

Not streaming yet
Check back soon

The Caribbean Mystery was released on June 1, 1945 but we couldn't find it on any streaming service yet. Rights can change — try again later.

Get the app to be notified

Cast · Directed by Robert D. Webb

JDJames Dunn
James Dunn
Mr. Smith
SRSheila Ryan
Sheila Ryan
Mrs. Jean Gilbert
EREdward Ryan
Edward Ryan
Gerald McCracken Jr.
JP
Jackie Paley
Linda Lane
RHReed Hadley
Reed Hadley
Dr. Rene Marcel
RRRoy Roberts
Roy Roberts
Capt. Van den Bark
RSRobert Shaw
Robert Shaw
Lt. Bowman Hall
DH
Daral Hudson
Hartshorn
WFWilliam Forrest
William Forrest
Col. Lane
RGRoy Gordon
Roy Gordon
Gov. Gerald McCracken Sr.
VWVirginia Walker
Virginia Walker
Adelaide Marcel

More from James Dunn · Lead actor

The Fugitive
The Fugitive
1963 · 7.3
Bonanza
Bonanza
1959 · 7.5
The Virginian
The Virginian
1962 · 6.5
Matinee Theater
Matinee Theater
1955 · 5.3
Rawhide
Rawhide
1959 · 7.2
Robert Montgomery Presents
Robert Montgomery Presents
1950 · 6.0
Studio One
Studio One
1948 · 5.4
Climax!
Climax!
1954 · 3.8
Wanted: Dead or Alive
Wanted: Dead or Alive
1958 · 7.0
Route 66
Route 66
1960 · 6.7
See all fromJames Dunn

More from Sheila Ryan · Co-star actress

The Lone Ranger
The Lone Ranger
1949 · 6.8
The Gene Autry Show
The Gene Autry Show
1950 · 4.7
I'm the Law
I'm the Law
1953 · 6.0
Great Guns
Great Guns
1941 · 6.0
Ringside
Ringside
1949 · 5.0
The Gang's All Here
The Gang's All Here
1943 · 5.9
Careful, Soft Shoulders
Careful, Soft Shoulders
1942 · 6.5
Gold Raiders
Gold Raiders
1951 · 6.6
Hideout
Hideout
1949 · 5.9
Dressed to Kill
Dressed to Kill
1941 · 6.3
See all fromSheila Ryan

More from Robert D. Webb · Director

Daniel Boone
Daniel Boone
1964 · 7.0
White Feather
White Feather
1955 · 6.8
Jesse James
Jesse James
1939 · 6.5
Blood and Sand
Blood and Sand
1941 · 6.5
Love Me Tender
Love Me Tender
1956 · 6.2
In Old Chicago
In Old Chicago
1938 · 6.7
On the Threshold of Space
On the Threshold of Space
1956 · 6.0
Captain Newman, M.D.
Captain Newman, M.D.
1963 · 6.7
A Gathering of Eagles
A Gathering of Eagles
1963 · 5.9
The Proud Ones
The Proud Ones
1956 · 6.5
See all fromRobert D. Webb

More like this

The Mirror Crack'd
The Mirror Crack'd
1980 · 6.1
Murder in Three Acts
Murder in Three Acts
1986 · 6.0
Witness to Murder
Witness to Murder
1954 · 6.3
A Bundle of Trouble: An Aurora Teagarden Mystery
A Bundle of Trouble: An Aurora Teagarden Mystery
2017 · 6.9
The Julius House: An Aurora Teagarden Mystery
The Julius House: An Aurora Teagarden Mystery
2016 · 6.9
Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Haunted By Murder
Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Haunted By Murder
2022 · 7.0
Site Unseen: An Emma Fielding Mystery
Site Unseen: An Emma Fielding Mystery
2017 · 6.8
Plunder Road
Plunder Road
1957 · 7.0
Miss Marple: They Do It with Mirrors
Miss Marple: They Do It with Mirrors
1991 · 6.9
Sherlock: The Abominable Bride
Sherlock: The Abominable Bride
2016 · 7.8
Little Caesar
Little Caesar
1931 · 6.9
The Interview
The Interview
1998 · 6.8

The Caribbean Mystery — streaming FAQ

Which OTT platform streams The Caribbean Mystery?

The Caribbean Mystery isn't streaming anywhere in Canada yet.

Is The Caribbean Mystery on Netflix?

No, The Caribbean Mystery is not on Netflix in Canada as of September 2026.

Is The Caribbean Mystery on Amazon Prime Video?

No, The Caribbean Mystery isn't on Amazon Prime Video in Canada right now.

Where can I watch The Caribbean Mystery for free?

The Caribbean Mystery isn't streaming in Canada yet, so there's no way to watch it free at the moment.

What is the OTT release date for The Caribbean Mystery?

The Caribbean Mystery hasn't started streaming in Canada yet. Based on the typical 6–8 week theatrical-to-streaming window, we estimate it will arrive around July 20, 1945. This is a prediction, not a confirmed date.