The Forbidden Wish poster
Where to stream

The Forbidden Wish

20211h 47mNRMovieDrama

A troubled young man retreats into his childhood synagogue, where a chance meeting with the Rabbi leads to an existential discussion exploring deeply-held issues of relationships, mental health, and faith, leading both men to confront the ultimate choice.

DirectorMichael Carnick
WriterMichael Carnick

Where to watch

Amazon Prime VideoAmazon Prime VideoAmazon Prime Video with AdsAmazon Prime Video with AdsTubi TVTubi TVPlexPlex
Availability shown for Canada · rights vary by country

Cast · Directed by Michael Carnick

SRSammi Rotibi
Sammi Rotibi
Nate
JBJohnny Berchtold
Johnny Berchtold
Isaac
BDBodhi Dell
Bodhi Dell
Elad
MB
Maximus Birchmore
Hiram
RS
Rahi Sarbaziha
Doctor Rodricks
JM
Jeff Myers
Cellist / EMT 1
MW
Myla Wingard
Violinist / EMT 2

More from Sammi Rotibi · Lead actor

Chicago P.D.
Chicago P.D.
2014 · 8.4
The Blacklist
The Blacklist
2013 · 7.6
Scorpion
Scorpion
2014 · 8.2
NCIS: New Orleans
NCIS: New Orleans
2014 · 7.3
MacGyver
MacGyver
2016 · 7.3
NCIS: Origins
NCIS: Origins
2024 · 7.5
The Division
The Division
2001 · 7.1
Django Unchained
Django Unchained
2012 · 8.2
Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice
Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice
2016 · 6.0
Lord of War
Lord of War
2005 · 7.4
See all fromSammi Rotibi

More from Johnny Berchtold · Co-star actor

Reacher
Reacher
2022 · 8.1
Manhunt
Manhunt
2017 · 7.6
The Wilds
The Wilds
2020 · 7.6
Tiny Beautiful Things
Tiny Beautiful Things
2023 · 6.8
Murdaugh: Death in the Family
Murdaugh: Death in the Family
2025 · 6.9
Gaslit
Gaslit
2022 · 6.8
Broke
Broke
2025 · 6.9
Murder Among Friends
Murder Among Friends
2016 · 7.4
The Passenger
The Passenger
2023 · 6.4
Life as a Mermaid
Life as a Mermaid
2016
See all fromJohnny Berchtold

More like this

Here
Here
2024 · 6.5
Won't Back Down
Won't Back Down
2012 · 6.2
Vanya on 42nd Street
Vanya on 42nd Street
1994 · 6.7
All Together Now
All Together Now
2020 · 6.7
The Truth About Emanuel
The Truth About Emanuel
2013 · 6.0
My Neighbor Adolf
My Neighbor Adolf
2022 · 6.6
Eleanor the Great
Eleanor the Great
2025 · 6.8
Lady Driver
Lady Driver
2020 · 6.4
Avalon
Avalon
1990 · 6.7
I Believe
I Believe
2019 · 7.8
Greyfriars Bobby
Greyfriars Bobby
1961 · 6.9
Skater Girl
Skater Girl
2021 · 7.2

The Forbidden Wish — streaming FAQ

Which OTT platform streams The Forbidden Wish?

The Forbidden Wish is streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Tubi TV and Plex in Canada, and available to rent or buy on Apple TV Store and YouTube. It's not currently on Netflix.

Is The Forbidden Wish on Netflix?

No, The Forbidden Wish is not on Netflix in Canada as of November 2026. It's currently on Amazon Prime Video and Tubi TV.

Is The Forbidden Wish on Amazon Prime Video?

Yes — The Forbidden Wish is included with an Amazon Prime Video subscription in Canada as of November 2026.

Where can I watch The Forbidden Wish for free?

The Forbidden Wish is available to stream free (with ads) on Tubi TV and Plex in Canada.