Elder Island poster
Where to stream

Elder Island

3.420161h 21mMovieThrillerHorror

Based on the true events revolving around Beaver Island, Michigan and King James Strang--Elder Island, 1856. Peter Wiggenstein turned to the men of the five island families around him and warned: "Tell nothing of this" as the men all…

DirectorDarrin James
WritersDarrin James·Fabricio Cerioni

Where to watch

FawesomeFawesomeTubi TVTubi TV
Availability shown for United States · rights vary by country

Cast · Directed by Darrin James

JBJamie Bernadette
Jamie Bernadette
Stacy Ryerson
JTJordan Trovillion
Jordan Trovillion
Brooke Ree
ASAlora Catherine Smith
Alora Catherine Smith
Andrea
DHDan Hicks
Dan Hicks
Lucas Heidegger
MA
Melissa Anschutz
Maria Wiggenstein
MB
Michael Robert Brandon
The Reverend
NSNate Scholz
Nate Scholz
Ned Ryerson
TQTimothy Patrick Quill
Timothy Patrick Quill
Sheriff Ree
JR
Jake Rotger
Reverend Son
SP
Sean Peavy
Sam Wiggenstein
JFJohnny Flynn
Johnny Flynn
Robert Looks
DD
Donavan Darius
Jacob Wiggenstein

More from Jamie Bernadette · Lead actress

Chicago Fire
Chicago Fire
2012 · 8.4
NCIS: New Orleans
NCIS: New Orleans
2014 · 7.3
Legends
Legends
2014 · 6.4
She Rides Shotgun
She Rides Shotgun
2025 · 7.0
Tell Me You Love Me
Tell Me You Love Me
2007 · 6.5
Mortdecai
Mortdecai
2015 · 5.5
As Luck Would Have It
As Luck Would Have It
2023 · 5.7
Milf
Milf
2010 · 4.3
Celebrity Sex Tape
Celebrity Sex Tape
2012 · 4.4
I Spit on Your Grave: Déjà Vu
I Spit on Your Grave: Déjà Vu
2019 · 3.0
See all fromJamie Bernadette

More from Jordan Trovillion · Co-star actress

MacGyver
MacGyver
2016 · 7.3
Jack Reacher
Jack Reacher
2012 · 6.7
Detroiters
Detroiters
2017 · 7.2
The Old Man & the Gun
The Old Man & the Gun
2018 · 6.4
Trust
Trust
2010 · 6.6
Hillbilly Elegy
Hillbilly Elegy
2020 · 6.7
Vanishing on 7th Street
Vanishing on 7th Street
2010 · 5.3
Gotti
Gotti
2018 · 5.3
My Days of Mercy
My Days of Mercy
2018 · 7.3
Setup
Setup
2011 · 4.8
See all fromJordan Trovillion

More like this

April Fool's Day
April Fool's Day
1986 · 6.0
Blink Twice
Blink Twice
2024 · 6.7
Dark Harvest
Dark Harvest
2023 · 6.1
Silver Bullet
Silver Bullet
1985 · 6.7
American Gothic
American Gothic
1987 · 5.9
The Wicker Man
The Wicker Man
1973 · 7.3
Clown in a Cornfield
Clown in a Cornfield
2025 · 6.1
Infinity Pool
Infinity Pool
2023 · 6.0
Jeepers Creepers
Jeepers Creepers
2001 · 6.5
Dangerous
Dangerous
2021 · 6.0
Isle of the Dead
Isle of the Dead
1945 · 6.0
The Last Breath
The Last Breath
2024 · 6.0

Elder Island — streaming FAQ

Which OTT platform streams Elder Island?

Elder Island is streaming on Fawesome and Tubi TV in United States, and available to rent or buy on Amazon Video and Fandango At Home. It's not currently on Netflix.

Is Elder Island on Netflix?

No, Elder Island is not on Netflix in United States as of October 2026. It's currently on Fawesome and Tubi TV.

Is Elder Island on Amazon Prime Video?

Elder Island isn't included with a Prime Video subscription in United States, but you can rent or buy it on Amazon Video.

Where can I watch Elder Island for free?

Elder Island is available to stream free (with ads) on Fawesome and Tubi TV in United States.