Second Guessing Fate poster
Where to stream

Second Guessing Fate

6.820251h 25mMovieRomanceComedyTV Movie

Gemma has given up on dating until a fortune teller predicts she's one last horrible date away from true love. When she goes on a date with Nick, anything and everything goes wrong, including crashing her car into a handsome and wealthy stranger.

DirectorStefan Brogren
WritersAlexandra Mircheff·Shelley Scarrow
ProducersArnie Zipursky·Dayna Zipursky

Where to watch

The CWThe CW
Availability shown for United States · rights vary by country

Cast · Directed by Stefan Brogren

DPDanielle Panabaker
Danielle Panabaker
Gemma
CSCorey Sevier
Corey Sevier
Nick
BMBrendan Morgan
Brendan Morgan
Enzo
JCJocelyn Chugg
Jocelyn Chugg
Helen
ARAri Rombough
Ari Rombough
Calvin (Uncredited)
BMBarb Mitchell
Barb Mitchell
Leslie
DS
Davina Stewart
Barbara
CGCatherine Gell
Catherine Gell
Madame Morgana
AP
Adeline Pearce
Birthday Girl
MB
Maya Baker
Waitress (Dive bar)
ND
Nick Duske
Baseball player- bar fight (Uncredited)
RERory Edgar
Rory Edgar
Handsome Uncle (Uncredited)

More from Danielle Panabaker · Lead actress

Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
1999 · 8.0
Family Guy
Family Guy
1999 · 7.4
The Flash
The Flash
2014 · 7.7
Grey's Anatomy
Grey's Anatomy
2005 · 8.2
Malcolm in the Middle
Malcolm in the Middle
2000 · 8.5
Medium
Medium
2005 · 7.5
CSI: Crime Scene Investigation
CSI: Crime Scene Investigation
2000 · 7.6
Bones
Bones
2005 · 8.2
Arrow
Arrow
2012 · 6.8
Grimm
Grimm
2011 · 8.3
See all fromDanielle Panabaker

More from Corey Sevier · Co-star actor

Supernatural
Supernatural
2005 · 8.3
Smallville
Smallville
2001 · 8.2
CSI: Miami
CSI: Miami
2002 · 7.7
Murdoch Mysteries
Murdoch Mysteries
2008 · 7.7
Psych
Psych
2006 · 7.9
Heartland
Heartland
2007 · 8.3
Private Eyes
Private Eyes
2016 · 7.3
Goosebumps
Goosebumps
1995 · 8.0
The Listener
The Listener
2009 · 6.9
Motive
Motive
2013 · 6.5
See all fromCorey Sevier

More from Stefan Brogren · Director

Degrassi
Degrassi
2001 · 7.6
Degrassi: Next Class
Degrassi: Next Class
2016 · 6.9
The L.A. Complex
The L.A. Complex
2012 · 5.0
The Night She Disappeared
The Night She Disappeared
2026
When I Said I Do
When I Said I Do
2026 · 6.3
Thank God: Christmas at Keller Ranch
Thank God: Christmas at Keller Ranch
2025 · 3.0
Dateless to Dangerous: My Son's Secret Life
Dateless to Dangerous: My Son's Secret Life
2025 · 7.0
A Chance for Christmas
A Chance for Christmas
2021 · 5.3
Hidden Family Secrets
Hidden Family Secrets
2021 · 5.7
If I Go Missing
If I Go Missing
2024 · 6.2
See all fromStefan Brogren

More like this

The Wrong Paris
The Wrong Paris
2025 · 6.7
Prom Pact
Prom Pact
2023 · 7.2
As Luck Would Have It
As Luck Would Have It
2021 · 6.5
Love, Weddings & Other Disasters
Love, Weddings & Other Disasters
2020 · 6.0
Relationship Goals
Relationship Goals
2026 · 6.4
What's Your Number?
What's Your Number?
2011 · 6.5
About Fate
About Fate
2022 · 7.5
Anything for Love
Anything for Love
2016 · 6.0
Starting Over
Starting Over
1979 · 6.4
You Cast A Spell On Me
You Cast A Spell On Me
2015 · 6.8
Long Weekend
Long Weekend
2021 · 6.8
A Christmas Miracle for Daisy
A Christmas Miracle for Daisy
2021 · 5.9

Second Guessing Fate — streaming FAQ

Which OTT platform streams Second Guessing Fate?

Second Guessing Fate is streaming on The CW in United States. It's not currently on Netflix.

Is Second Guessing Fate on Netflix?

No, Second Guessing Fate is not on Netflix in United States as of November 2026. It's currently on The CW.

Is Second Guessing Fate on Amazon Prime Video?

No, Second Guessing Fate isn't on Amazon Prime Video in United States right now. It's on The CW instead.

Where can I watch Second Guessing Fate for free?

Second Guessing Fate is available to stream free (with ads) on The CW in United States.