The Wrong Sarah poster
Where to stream

The Wrong Sarah

2.820211h 3mMovieHorrorCrimeThriller

An FBI agent, on the trail of a serial killer who has travelled the country is targeting women with the same name, rushes to protect the next possible victim.

DirectorJason Toler
WriterJason Toler
ProducersGregory Hatanaka·Jason Toler

Where to watch

Amazon Prime VideoAmazon Prime VideoAmazon Prime Video with AdsAmazon Prime Video with AdsTroma NOWTroma NOWFawesomeFawesomePlexPlexPlex ChannelPlex ChannelCineverseCineverseTubi TVTubi TV
Availability shown for United States · rights vary by country

Cast · Directed by Jason Toler

JTJason Toler
Jason Toler
FBI Agent Lance Roberts
CSChris Spinelli
Chris Spinelli
FBI Agent Will King
LLLisa London
Lisa London
Lilian Hill
CLChristina Lo
Christina Lo
FBI Agent Stacy Lue
SRShane Ryan-Reid
Shane Ryan-Reid
Killer
SBSarah Brine
Sarah Brine
First Victim Sarah

More from Jason Toler · Lead actor

Pleasure
Pleasure
2021 · 6.3
Barbershop
Barbershop
2002 · 6.5
Backfire
Backfire
2023
Kill Plan
Kill Plan
2021 · 5.8
Crack House of the Dead
Crack House of the Dead
2021 · 2.0
Night Cops
Night Cops
2023 · 1.0
The Wedding Pact 2: The Baby Pact
The Wedding Pact 2: The Baby Pact
2021 · 5.0
Another Way To Die
Another Way To Die
2022
Body of Night
Body of Night
2020 · 2.5
The Awakening of Emanuelle
The Awakening of Emanuelle
2021 · 2.5
See all fromJason Toler

More from Chris Spinelli · Co-star actor

Georgie & Mandy's First Marriage
Georgie & Mandy's First Marriage
2024 · 8.0
How to Get Away with Murder
How to Get Away with Murder
2014 · 7.8
You Don't Mess with the Zohan
You Don't Mess with the Zohan
2008 · 5.7
Cloverfield
Cloverfield
2008 · 6.7
The Ugly Truth
The Ugly Truth
2009 · 6.5
Shadow Death
Shadow Death
2025
Seeking a Friend for the End of the World
Seeking a Friend for the End of the World
2012 · 6.6
Yakuza Girl
Yakuza Girl
2024
Amor Emanuelle
Amor Emanuelle
2023 · 4.5
Crack
Crack
2023 · 5.0
See all fromChris Spinelli

More like this

Mindcage
Mindcage
2022 · 5.9
Cult Killer
Cult Killer
2024 · 6.4
All the Devils Are Here
All the Devils Are Here
2025 · 6.2
The Virtuoso
The Virtuoso
2021 · 5.9
In the Blood
In the Blood
2014 · 5.8
Cleaner
Cleaner
2007 · 6.1
Frank and Penelope
Frank and Penelope
2022 · 7.3
War
War
2007 · 6.4
Ted Bundy: American Boogeyman
Ted Bundy: American Boogeyman
2021 · 6.6
Absolution
Absolution
2024 · 5.9
Night of the Hunted
Night of the Hunted
2023 · 6.1
Bloodline
Bloodline
2019 · 5.9

The Wrong Sarah — streaming FAQ

Which OTT platform streams The Wrong Sarah?

The Wrong Sarah is streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Troma NOW and Fawesome in United States, and available to rent or buy on Amazon Video and Apple TV Store. It's not currently on Netflix.

Is The Wrong Sarah on Netflix?

No, The Wrong Sarah is not on Netflix in United States as of October 2026. It's currently on Amazon Prime Video and Troma NOW.

Is The Wrong Sarah on Amazon Prime Video?

Yes — The Wrong Sarah is included with an Amazon Prime Video subscription in United States as of October 2026.

Where can I watch The Wrong Sarah for free?

The Wrong Sarah is available to stream free (with ads) on Fawesome and Plex in United States.