I'm Not Gay : A Musical poster
Where to stream

I'm Not Gay : A Musical

1.020231h 41mMovieDramaMusic

Plagued by a hidden childhood trauma that is destroying his life, an obsessive-compulsive MMA fighter moves to Fire Island and pretends to be gay in order to buy the house of his dreams and exorcise his demons.

DirectorScott L. Semer
WriterScott L. Semer
ProducerCarrie Ormond

Where to watch

Amazon Prime VideoAmazon Prime VideoAmazon Prime Video with AdsAmazon Prime Video with AdsHooplaHooplaFandango at Home FreeFandango at Home FreePlexPlexPlex ChannelPlex ChannelTubi TVTubi TV
Availability shown for United States · rights vary by country

Cast · Directed by Scott L. Semer

SHSydney James Harcourt
Sydney James Harcourt
Misha
AJAlan Mingo Jr.
Alan Mingo Jr.
Maxi
BBBrad Bradley
Brad Bradley
Rush
GDGeorge Dvorsky
George Dvorsky
Mr. Osborne
GSGriffin Santopietro
Griffin Santopietro
Carey

More from Sydney James Harcourt · Lead actor

FBI
FBI
2018 · 7.9
Person of Interest
Person of Interest
2011 · 8.1
Elementary
Elementary
2012 · 7.6
The Good Wife
The Good Wife
2009 · 7.6
Younger
Younger
2015 · 6.9
Tell Me a Story
Tell Me a Story
2018 · 7.1
Castlevania: Nocturne
Castlevania: Nocturne
2023 · 7.8
Gone
Gone
2018 · 7.2
Hamilton
Hamilton
2025 · 7.9
Boys On Film 20: Heaven Can Wait
Boys On Film 20: Heaven Can Wait
2020 · 3.5
See all fromSydney James Harcourt

More from Alan Mingo Jr. · Co-star actor

Law & Order
Law & Order
1990 · 7.3
Doom Patrol
Doom Patrol
2019 · 7.5
Marvel's Jessica Jones
Marvel's Jessica Jones
2015 · 7.5
Tales of the City
Tales of the City
2019 · 6.8
The Hunter
The Hunter
2020
See all fromAlan Mingo Jr.

More like this

Fight Club
Fight Club
1999 · 8.4
The Three Faces of Eve
The Three Faces of Eve
1957 · 7.2
Whitney Houston: I Wanna Dance with Somebody
Whitney Houston: I Wanna Dance with Somebody
2022 · 7.0
Springsteen: Deliver Me from Nowhere
Springsteen: Deliver Me from Nowhere
2025 · 6.6
The Normal Heart
The Normal Heart
2014 · 7.7
Beast
Beast
2026 · 7.5
The Smashing Machine
The Smashing Machine
2025 · 6.4
Coda
Coda
2020 · 6.0
The Punisher: One Last Kill
The Punisher: One Last Kill
2026 · 8.3
Battle of the Year
Battle of the Year
2013 · 6.8
Boy Erased
Boy Erased
2018 · 7.0
Mo' Better Blues
Mo' Better Blues
1990 · 6.5

I'm Not Gay : A Musical — streaming FAQ

Which OTT platform streams I'm Not Gay : A Musical?

I'm Not Gay : A Musical is streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Hoopla and Fandango at Home Free in United States, and available to rent or buy on Amazon Video and Apple TV Store. It's not currently on Netflix.

Is I'm Not Gay : A Musical on Netflix?

No, I'm Not Gay : A Musical is not on Netflix in United States as of September 2026. It's currently on Amazon Prime Video and Hoopla.

Is I'm Not Gay : A Musical on Amazon Prime Video?

Yes — I'm Not Gay : A Musical is included with an Amazon Prime Video subscription in United States as of September 2026.

Where can I watch I'm Not Gay : A Musical for free?

I'm Not Gay : A Musical is available to stream free (with ads) on Hoopla and Fandango at Home Free in United States.