Return of the Tooth Fairy poster
Where to stream

Return of the Tooth Fairy

6.520201h 31mNRMovieHorror

The Tooth Fairy is back. 15 years after the events of the first movie, Corey, now grown up but mentally scarred has gone to a class reunion. However, the Tooth Fairy is back, and this time - You better have flossed properly.

DirectorLouisa Warren
WriterTom Jolliffe
ProducersNicole Holland·Louisa Warren

Where to watch

Tubi TVTubi TVPlexPlex
Availability shown for Canada · rights vary by country

Cast · Directed by Louisa Warren

JWJake Watkins
Jake Watkins
Corey
KMKatie McKenna
Katie McKenna
Jess
GFGus Fithen
Gus Fithen
Gus
CGChelsea Greenwood
Chelsea Greenwood
Jo
SM
Simon Manley
Ray
ABAJ Blackwell
AJ Blackwell
Paul
VC
Venetia Cook
Hazel
AB
Amy Blackthorne
Danielle
JH
Jenna Harris
Tammy
HJHeather Jackson
Heather Jackson
Marg
AS
Anabel Saise
Toothfairy
NS
Niru Sukanthan
Toothfairy (voice)

More from Jake Watkins · Lead actor

Patterns
Patterns
2023
Cupid
Cupid
2020 · 3.6
The Gardener
The Gardener
2021 · 4.9
A Series of Light
A Series of Light
2020
Werewolf Castle
Werewolf Castle
2022 · 5.0
The Haunting of the Tower of London
The Haunting of the Tower of London
2022 · 5.8
Don't Speak
Don't Speak
2020 · 4.7
It Came from Below
It Came from Below
2021 · 5.1
Lord of Wolves
Lord of Wolves
2024
Freeze
Freeze
2022 · 3.9
See all fromJake Watkins

More from Louisa Warren · Director

Dirty Work
Dirty Work
2018 · 4.4
Cinderella's Curse
Cinderella's Curse
2024 · 5.9
Wizard of Oz: Dead Walk
Wizard of Oz: Dead Walk
2025 · 4.8
Escapee
Escapee
2023 · 2.7
Bride of Frankenstein Awakens
Bride of Frankenstein Awakens
2026 · 5.0
Bride of Scarecrow
Bride of Scarecrow
2018 · 5.5
The Leprechaun's Game
The Leprechaun's Game
2020 · 2.0
Scarecrow's Revenge
Scarecrow's Revenge
2019 · 4.3
The Viking War
The Viking War
2019 · 5.0
Christmas with the Prince
Christmas with the Prince
2023 · 5.5
See all fromLouisa Warren

More like this

Silver Bullet
Silver Bullet
1985 · 6.7
The Jester
The Jester
2023 · 6.1
The Jack in the Box Rises
The Jack in the Box Rises
2024 · 6.5
Deep Water
Deep Water
2026 · 7.1
Siren
Siren
2016 · 5.9
The Shed
The Shed
2019 · 5.9
The Possessed
The Possessed
2021 · 6.3
The Blob
The Blob
1958 · 6.2
The Apology
The Apology
2022 · 5.8
The Haunting Hour: Don't Think About It
The Haunting Hour: Don't Think About It
2007 · 6.8
Angels Fallen: Warriors of Peace
Angels Fallen: Warriors of Peace
2024 · 5.9
Eradication
Eradication
2022 · 6.1

Return of the Tooth Fairy — streaming FAQ

Which OTT platform streams Return of the Tooth Fairy?

Return of the Tooth Fairy is streaming on Tubi TV and Plex in Canada. It's not currently on Netflix.

Is Return of the Tooth Fairy on Netflix?

No, Return of the Tooth Fairy is not on Netflix in Canada as of September 2026. It's currently on Tubi TV and Plex.

Is Return of the Tooth Fairy on Amazon Prime Video?

No, Return of the Tooth Fairy isn't on Amazon Prime Video in Canada right now. It's on Tubi TV and Plex instead.

Where can I watch Return of the Tooth Fairy for free?

Return of the Tooth Fairy is available to stream free (with ads) on Tubi TV and Plex in Canada.

Is there a sequel to Return of the Tooth Fairy?

Yes — Return of the Tooth Fairy is followed by Tooth Fairy: The Last Extraction (2021) in the Tooth Fairy (Horror) Collection.

Is there a prequel to Return of the Tooth Fairy?

Yes — Tooth Fairy (2019) comes before Return of the Tooth Fairy in the Tooth Fairy (Horror) Collection.

Is Return of the Tooth Fairy part of a trilogy?

No — Return of the Tooth Fairy is part of the Tooth Fairy (Horror) Collection, which has 5 films.

How many movies are in the Tooth Fairy (Horror) Collection?

There are 5 films in the Tooth Fairy (Horror) Collection: Tooth Fairy (2019), Return of the Tooth Fairy (2020), Tooth Fairy: The Last Extraction (2021), Tooth Fairy: Queen of Pain (2022) and Tooth Fairy: Drill to Kill (2022).