Mystery Island: Play for Keeps poster
Where to stream

Mystery Island: Play for Keeps

7.320251h 24mMovieMysteryAdventureTV Movie

Mystery Island hosts a corporate retreat with a guest being Emilia's ex-fiancé. Old feelings become complicated, tensions run high, and allegations arise when a guest is found dead.

DirectorSteven R. Monroe
WriterJohn Christian Plummer

Where to watch

fuboTVfuboTVPhiloPhiloHallmark+ Amazon ChannelHallmark+ Amazon ChannelHallmark+ Apple TV channelHallmark+ Apple TV channelHallmark TV Amazon ChannelHallmark TV Amazon Channel
Availability shown for United States · rights vary by country

Cast · Directed by Steven R. Monroe

EHElizabeth Henstridge
Elizabeth Henstridge
Dr. Emilia Priestly
CWCharlie Weber
Charlie Weber
Jason Trent
KBKezia Burrows
Kezia Burrows
Baroness Jane Alcott
EEEmily Eaton-Plowright
Emily Eaton-Plowright
Ainsley Trask
KMKris Mochrie
Kris Mochrie
Franklin Trask
VB
Victoria Bolt
Viveca Bentley
JMJohn Macdonald
John Macdonald
Spencer Trask
NANisha Aaliya
Nisha Aaliya
Patricia Collacello
BWBarney White
Barney White
Mickey Carlyle
SBSuanne Braun
Suanne Braun
Morgan Bennett
BM
Ben McKeown
Simmons
RDRandy Domínguez
Randy Domínguez
Ray Romero

More from Elizabeth Henstridge · Lead actress

Marvel's Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.
Marvel's Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.
2013 · 7.5
Superman & Lois
Superman & Lois
2021 · 8.1
Penn Zero: Part-Time Hero
Penn Zero: Part-Time Hero
2014 · 7.2
Suspicion
Suspicion
2022 · 6.7
Marvel's Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.: Slingshot
Marvel's Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.: Slingshot
2016 · 7.1
Wolves at the Door
Wolves at the Door
2016 · 4.9
Mystery Island
Mystery Island
2023 · 5.9
Reach Me
Reach Me
2014 · 5.2
Christmas at the Plaza
Christmas at the Plaza
2019 · 6.4
The Thompsons
The Thompsons
2012 · 4.7
See all fromElizabeth Henstridge

More from Charlie Weber · Co-star actor

House
House
2004 · 8.6
CSI: Crime Scene Investigation
CSI: Crime Scene Investigation
2000 · 7.6
Bones
Bones
2005 · 8.2
CSI: Miami
CSI: Miami
2002 · 7.7
Charmed
Charmed
1998 · 8.2
Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Buffy the Vampire Slayer
1997 · 8.1
CSI: NY
CSI: NY
2004 · 7.3
Everwood
Everwood
2002 · 7.6
How to Get Away with Murder
How to Get Away with Murder
2014 · 7.8
The Drew Carey Show
The Drew Carey Show
1995 · 6.5
See all fromCharlie Weber

More from Steven R. Monroe · Director

I Spit on Your Grave
I Spit on Your Grave
2010 · 6.5
I Spit on Your Grave 2
I Spit on Your Grave 2
2013 · 6.3
House of 9
House of 9
2005 · 5.1
Ice Twisters
Ice Twisters
2009 · 5.9
Mongolian Death Worm
Mongolian Death Worm
2010 · 4.8
Ties That Bind
Ties That Bind
2015 · 6.0
Taken Heart
Taken Heart
2017 · 3.8
The Exorcism of Molly Hartley
The Exorcism of Molly Hartley
2015 · 5.0
The 12 Disasters of Christmas
The 12 Disasters of Christmas
2012 · 4.6
Undercover Angel
Undercover Angel
2017 · 6.2
See all fromSteven R. Monroe

More like this

Mystery Island
Mystery Island
2023 · 5.9
Curious Caterer: Dying for Chocolate
Curious Caterer: Dying for Chocolate
2022 · 6.8
Miss Marple: The Murder at the Vicarage
Miss Marple: The Murder at the Vicarage
1986 · 6.7
River Wild
River Wild
2023 · 6.4
Miss Marple: A Caribbean Mystery
Miss Marple: A Caribbean Mystery
1989 · 6.7
Jesse Stone: Benefit of the Doubt
Jesse Stone: Benefit of the Doubt
2012 · 6.8
Invisible Sister
Invisible Sister
2015 · 6.7
Mystery 101: Playing Dead
Mystery 101: Playing Dead
2019 · 7.5
A Bone to Pick: An Aurora Teagarden Mystery
A Bone to Pick: An Aurora Teagarden Mystery
2015 · 6.9
Crossword Mysteries: Riddle Me Dead
Crossword Mysteries: Riddle Me Dead
2021 · 7.4
Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: How to Con A Con
Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: How to Con A Con
2021 · 7.2
Scooby-Doo
Scooby-Doo
2002 · 6.1

Mystery Island: Play for Keeps — streaming FAQ

Which OTT platform streams Mystery Island: Play for Keeps?

Mystery Island: Play for Keeps is streaming on fuboTV, Philo and Hallmark+ in United States. It's not currently on Netflix.

Is Mystery Island: Play for Keeps on Netflix?

No, Mystery Island: Play for Keeps is not on Netflix in United States as of September 2026. It's currently on fuboTV and Philo.

Is Mystery Island: Play for Keeps on Amazon Prime Video?

No, Mystery Island: Play for Keeps isn't on Amazon Prime Video in United States right now. It's on fuboTV and Philo instead.

Where can I watch Mystery Island: Play for Keeps for free?

Mystery Island: Play for Keeps is available on fuboTV and Philo in United States, but you'll need an active subscription — there's no free option right now.

Is there a sequel to Mystery Island: Play for Keeps?

Yes — Mystery Island: Play for Keeps is followed by Mystery Island: House Rules (2025) in the Mystery Island Collection.

Is there a prequel to Mystery Island: Play for Keeps?

Yes — Mystery Island: Winner Takes All (2025) comes before Mystery Island: Play for Keeps in the Mystery Island Collection.

Is Mystery Island: Play for Keeps part of a trilogy?

No — Mystery Island: Play for Keeps is part of the Mystery Island Collection, which has 4 films.

How many movies are in the Mystery Island Collection?

There are 4 films in the Mystery Island Collection: Mystery Island (2023), Mystery Island: Winner Takes All (2025), Mystery Island: Play for Keeps (2025) and Mystery Island: House Rules (2025).